The Effects of Computational Resources on Flaky Tests

Flaky tests are tests that nondeterministically pass and fail in unchanged code. These tests can be detrimental to developers' productivity. Particularly when tests run in continuous integration environments, the tests may be competing for access to limited computational resources (CPUs, memory etc.), and we hypothesize that resource (in)availability may be a significant factor in the failure rate of flaky tests. We present the first assessment of the impact that computational resources have on flaky tests, including a total of 52 projects written in Java, JavaScript and Python, and 27 different resource configurations. Using a rigorous statistical methodology, we determine which tests are RAFT (Resource-Affected Flaky Tests). We find that 46.5% of the flaky tests in our dataset are RAFT, indicating that a substantial proportion of flaky-test failures can be avoided by adjusting the resources available when running tests. We report RAFTs and configurations to avoid them to developers, and received interest to either fix the RAFTs or to improve the specifications of the projects so that tests would be run only in configurations that are unlikely to encounter RAFT failures. Our results also have implications for researchers attempting to detect flaky tests, e.g., reducing the resources available when running tests is a cost-effective approach to detect more flaky failures.Comment: This work has been submitted to the IEEE for possible publication. Copyright may be transferred without notice, after which this version may no longer be accessibl